A Bargain Shop with a Bargain Share Price?
B&M European Value Retail SA (LON: BM)
B&M European Value Retail Interim FY25 Performance Review
B&M's share price took a sharp hit today, falling 7.66% following the release of its interim FY25 results. This decline adds to a troubling longer-term trend, with the stock down 34.64% over the past year and 6.55% over the past five years. Investors have endured a challenging period as concerns over the retailer's growth trajectory and profitability weigh heavily on market sentiment.
So, let’s take a look at all the noise and figure out what’s going on!
Overview: B&M European Value Retail S.A. reported its interim financial results for the 26 weeks ending September 28, 2024. This report delves into the company's financial and operational performance amidst evolving consumer behavior and macroeconomic headwinds. Key themes include revenue growth, cost management, profitability challenges, and strategic initiatives. The analysis draws on financial ratios, historical comparisons, and an evaluation of market dynamics to assess B&M's outlook.
1. Financial Performance Overview
Revenue Growth and Segment Analysis
The Group delivered a 3.7% YoY revenue growth, reaching £2,644m, with contributions from store expansions and volume growth. A closer breakdown reveals:
B&M UK:
Revenue increased 3.7% to £2,121m.
LFL sales contracted by 3.6%, following 5.1% declines in Q1 and a recovery to 1.9% declines in Q2.
Growth was driven by 7.3% from new stores, highlighting an aggressive expansion strategy.
B&M France:
Revenue rose by 6.8% to £247m.
Growth was attributed to new store openings and the optimization of product ranges, with improving FMCG and general merchandise categories.
Heron Foods:
Revenue grew modestly by 1.1% to £276m, reflecting resilience despite economic headwinds affecting lower-income demographics.
Consolidated Observations:
While revenue growth is notable, the reliance on new store openings raises questions about the sustainability of growth, especially as LFL performance remains weak. The company must address whether its current expansion pace can compensate for organic sales pressure, especially in a competitive retail landscape.
Profitability Trends
Profitability weakened despite revenue growth, reflecting increased costs and challenging macroeconomic conditions.
Key Observations:
Gross Margins: Improved to 37.7% (up 78 bps), driven by lower freight costs, favorable product mix shifts, and reduced markdowns.
Operating Margins: Adjusted operating profit margin declined by 190 bps, as higher operating costs, including wages and distribution expenses, weighed on results.
Statutory Profit: Declined 23.8% YoY to £169m, partly due to adjusting items such as a £19m loss on foreign exchange derivatives.
The erosion in operating margins underscores the challenges in balancing cost pressures and competitive pricing strategies. While cost control measures are evident, they were insufficient to offset wage inflation and expansion-related expenses.
2. Operational Metrics and Store Expansion
B&M’s growth strategy emphasizes store expansions across key geographies, with 39 gross new stores opened in H1 FY25:
UK: 30 stores (23 net).
France: 5 stores.
Heron Foods: 4 stores (3 net).
Store Economics:
Payback Period: New stores achieve profitability within 12 months, maintaining historical trends.
Investment: The company invested £50m in 35 stores (opened between April 2022 and September 2023), generating £50m in profit contributions.
Long-Term Store Targets:
B&M aims to increase its UK estate to 1,200 stores (currently 764 stores).
In France, long-term growth remains focused on leveraging "white space" opportunities, supported by enhanced supply chain infrastructure.
Analysis: While store-level economics remain robust, the focus on store openings raises concerns about market saturation and diminishing returns. As B&M approaches its UK target, growth will depend on its ability to drive LFL sales and optimize existing store performance.
3. Cost Management and Leverage
Operating Costs:
Adjusted operating costs increased 7.4% YoY to £721m, driven by:
Store network expansion.
Wage inflation, particularly due to higher minimum wage rates.
Investment in supply chain and distribution capacity.
Cost Ratios:
Net Debt and Leverage:
Net Debt: Increased to £788m (H1 FY24: £700m).
Net Debt/Adjusted EBITDA: Rose to 1.2x, within acceptable limits but reflective of working capital investments.
Including leases, leverage stood at 2.5x, marginally higher than the prior period.
B&M's ability to manage costs and maintain low leverage ratios demonstrates financial discipline. However, continued pressure on operating costs could challenge long-term profitability unless offset by stronger revenue growth.
4. Cash Flow Dynamics
Cash generation weakened, reflecting increased investments in working capital and inventory management.
Inventory Management:
Inventory rose to £1,007m, reflecting early procurement to mitigate supply chain risks.
This proactive strategy aligns with the need to secure availability during the "Golden Quarter," but it increases the risk of markdowns if consumer demand falters.
5. Dividend Policy and Shareholder Returns
B&M declared an interim dividend of 5.3p per share, up 3.9% YoY, reflecting confidence in cash flow generation.
Analysis: The increase aligns with B&M’s revised payout policy, targeting 40-50% of adjusted post-tax earnings. While appealing to shareholders, sustainability hinges on consistent free cash flow generation amidst rising costs.
6. Competitive Landscape
B&M operates in a highly competitive retail sector dominated by discount retailers such as Aldi and Lidl. These competitors excel in grocery and FMCG segments, overlapping with B&M's core categories.
Differentiation Strategy:
Focus on Everyday Low Prices (EDLP) to maintain competitiveness without relying on promotions.
Strengthened general merchandise offerings, particularly in home categories, to drive differentiation.
While B&M's value proposition resonates with consumers, maintaining its competitive edge requires continuous innovation in product mix and operational efficiency.
7. Risks and Strategic Considerations
Key Risks:
Macroeconomic Environment: Rising inflation and weaker disposable incomes may constrain consumer spending.
Regulatory Changes: Ongoing reviews of corporate domicile and tax policies add complexity.
Supply Chain Disruptions: Despite mitigation efforts, global tensions and freight volatility remain risks.
Strategic Focus Areas:
Improving LFL Sales: Addressing the consistent decline in organic growth through customer engagement and store optimization.
Digital and E-commerce: Exploring online opportunities, though constrained by the value retailer model.
Geographic Expansion: Leveraging growth potential in France while sustaining UK momentum.
Conclusion
It’s an interesting time for B&M and its shareholders, with strong growth potential on the horizon. However, as investors will have observed following the recent budget, the FTSE has seen a general decline, and B&M is no exception.
Investors should take note that the company’s debt has increased by £88m, but when managed effectively, debt can be a tool for growth. Operating costs have risen slightly, but if B&M can sustain its growth, particularly through its Heron Foods acquisition, it could be an undervalued stock in the current market.
Looking at the medium-term outlook, the cost of living will likely have an impact, as many consumers are already cutting back on spending, with food bills being a significant contributor. As people seek more affordable shopping options, B&M is well-positioned to offer an attractive choice, much like rivals ALDI and Lidl, who have made major inroads into the UK market.
Thanks for reading,
Ollz.
The information provided in this article is for informational purposes only and reflects my personal opinions and analyses. It should not be considered financial advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any securities. Investing in the stock market involves risks, and past performance is not indicative of future results. Readers are encouraged to conduct their own research and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decisions. I do not assume any responsibility for any financial losses or consequences that may arise from reliance on the information provided herein.
It is not that cheap, product wise